Slice of homemade pudding with raisins on a white plate

Recipe of The Week: Boiled Indian Pudding

Four or five hours of boiling for a dish made of cornmeal and milk. That's the kind of recipe that only makes sense when there's a fire going all day anyway, which there was.

Two warnings in Child's text are doing real work. First: the milk should be merely warm, not scalding, or "the pudding will break to pieces." Second: leave plenty of room in the pan or cloth, because "Indian swells very much." Both of those are the voice of someone who has opened a ruined pudding.

It's humble food that turns into something closer to a custard-grain hybrid after that long in the pot — sweet, dense, faintly gritty in a way that's the point rather than a flaw.

From the original, 1832

Indian pudding should be boiled four or five hours. Sifted Indian meal and warm milk should be stirred together pretty stiff. A little salt, and two or three great spoonfuls of molasses, added; a spoonful of ginger, if you like that spice. Boil it in a tight covered pan, or a very thick cloth; if the water gets in, it will ruin it. Leave plenty of room; for Indian swells very much. The milk with which you mix it should be merely warm; if it be scalding, the pudding will break to pieces. Some people chop sweet suet fine, and warm in the milk; others warm thin slices of sweet apple to be stirred into the pudding. Water will answer instead of milk.

What the old words mean

  • Suet — hard beef fat from around the kidneys; butter works
  • Boiled — steamed, really; the pudding sits sealed in a pan or cloth inside boiling water

In a modern kitchen

Use a covered pudding basin or a well-buttered metal bowl with foil crimped tight, set on a rack in a stockpot with water halfway up the side. Keep it at a bare simmer and top up the water. If four hours is more than you have, Child's own baked version runs three to four at 300°F and is nearly as good. The apple variation is the one worth making.

This recipe is from The American Frugal Housewife by Lydia Maria Child (Boston, 1832), which is in the public domain. The full book is free to read at Project Gutenberg.

Back to blog

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.